0 true 2009-08-30T06:16:01-05:00 68102 276 video-element-always-set-to-autoplay-even-when-youtube-isnt 135657 24342 fixreleased 1.5fc2 autoplay h.264 video youtube 2009-10-03T23:54:20-05:00 45213 rentzsch Stuart A. Malone http://rentzsch.lighthouseapp.com/projects/24342/tickets/276 When Clicktoflash 1.5fc2 converts YouTube video to <video> tags, it always sets autoplay regardless of whether the original video was set to autoplay. This is very annoying when I'm working in a room with others. It also leads to chaos on sites with multiple YouTube videos embedded on the same page, as often happens in my Google Reader feeds. For an example, see: http://cuteoverload.com/2009/08/29/more-snow-leopards-on-caturday/ ClickToFlash should respect the autoplay setting of the original video, though it would be nice (and be in the spirit of ClickToFlash) to have the option of never autoplaying video so that one isn't surprised by unexpected video. When Clicktoflash 1.5fc2 converts YouTube video to <video> tags, it always sets autoplay regardless of whether the original video was set to autoplay. This is very annoying when I'm working in a room with others. It also leads to chaos on sites with multiple YouTube videos embedded on the same page, as often happens in my Google Reader feeds. For an example, see: http://cuteoverload.com/2009/08/29/more-snow-leopards-on-caturday/ ClickToFlash should respect the autoplay setting of the original video, though it would be nice (and be in the spirit of ClickToFlash) to have the option of never autoplaying video so that one isn't surprised by unexpected video. <div><p>When Clicktoflash 1.5fc2 converts YouTube video to tags, it always sets autoplay regardless of whether the original video was set to autoplay. This is very annoying when I'm working in a room with others. It also leads to chaos on sites with multiple YouTube videos embedded on the same page, as often happens in my Google Reader feeds.</p> <p>For an example, see:</p> <p><a href= "http://cuteoverload.com/2009/08/29/more-snow-leopards-on-caturday/"> http://cuteoverload.com/2009/08/29/more-snow-leopards-on-caturday/</a></p> <p>ClickToFlash should respect the autoplay setting of the original video, though it would be nice (and be in the spirit of ClickToFlash) to have the option of never autoplaying video so that one isn't surprised by unexpected video.</p></div> 0 When Clicktoflash 1.5fc2 converts YouTube video to <video> tags, it always sets autoplay regardless of whether the original video was set to autoplay. This is very annoying when I'm working in a room with others. It also leads to chaos on sites with multiple YouTube videos embedded on the same page, as often happens in my Google Reader feeds. For an example, see: http://cuteoverload.com/2009/08/29/more-snow-leopards-on-caturday/ ClickToFlash should respect the autoplay setting of the original video, though it would be nice (and be in the spirit of ClickToFlash) to have the option of never autoplaying video so that one isn't surprised by unexpected video. <div><p>When Clicktoflash 1.5fc2 converts YouTube video to tags, it always sets autoplay regardless of whether the original video was set to autoplay. This is very annoying when I'm working in a room with others. It also leads to chaos on sites with multiple YouTube videos embedded on the same page, as often happens in my Google Reader feeds.</p> <p>For an example, see:</p> <p><a href= "http://cuteoverload.com/2009/08/29/more-snow-leopards-on-caturday/"> http://cuteoverload.com/2009/08/29/more-snow-leopards-on-caturday/</a></p> <p>ClickToFlash should respect the autoplay setting of the original video, though it would be nice (and be in the spirit of ClickToFlash) to have the option of never autoplaying video so that one isn't surprised by unexpected video.</p></div> false 2009-08-30T06:16:01-05:00 68102 --- {} 276 video-element-always-set-to-autoplay-even-when-youtube-isnt 0 24342 new 1.5fc2 autoplay h.264 video youtube 2009-08-30T13:52:14-05:00 68102 Stuart A. Malone Stuart A. Malone http://rentzsch.lighthouseapp.com/projects/24342/tickets/276 0 Glad this wasn't just me. I just opened kottke.org/ for the first time with the latest 1.5fc2 on Snow Leopard and about had a heart attack as 5 different YouTube videos started playing. As I had opened the site along with about 15 others, I frantically searched for the culprit! I think autoplay should definitely be off for YouTube <video> replacement tags (unless otherwise specified). <div><p>Glad this wasn't just me. I just opened kottke.org/ for the first time with the latest 1.5fc2 on Snow Leopard and about had a heart attack as 5 different YouTube videos started playing. As I had opened the site along with about 15 others, I frantically searched for the culprit!</p> <p>I think autoplay should definitely be off for YouTube replacement tags (unless otherwise specified).</p></div> false 2009-08-30T21:42:16-05:00 68102 --- {} 276 video-element-always-set-to-autoplay-even-when-youtube-isnt 0 24342 new 1.5fc2 autoplay h.264 video youtube 2009-08-30T21:42:20-05:00 1440 Kyle Rove Stuart A. Malone http://rentzsch.lighthouseapp.com/projects/24342/tickets/276 0 +1! I had this with 1.5b5 as well. Safari 4.0.3, OS X 10.5.8. Failcase URL, if you want a trumpet in your face: http://www.universalhub.com/node/27303 <div><p>+1! I had this with 1.5b5 as well. Safari 4.0.3, OS X 10.5.8.</p> <p>Failcase URL, if you want a trumpet in your face:</p> <p><a href= "http://www.universalhub.com/node/27303">http://www.universalhub.com/node/27303</a></p></div> false 2009-08-31T19:58:28-05:00 68102 --- {} 276 video-element-always-set-to-autoplay-even-when-youtube-isnt 0 24342 new 1.5fc2 autoplay h.264 video youtube 2009-08-31T19:58:29-05:00 10271 Jay Levitt Stuart A. Malone http://rentzsch.lighthouseapp.com/projects/24342/tickets/276 0 Hmm, I'm not seeing this? Like Jay, I'm on Mac OS X 10.5.8, Safari 4.0.3 and ClickToFlash 1.5fc2. <div><p>Hmm, I'm not seeing this? Like Jay, I'm on Mac OS X 10.5.8, Safari 4.0.3 and ClickToFlash 1.5fc2.</p></div> true 2009-09-01T11:56:34-05:00 68102 --- :state: new 276 video-element-always-set-to-autoplay-even-when-youtube-isnt 0 24342 cantreproduce 1.5fc2 autoplay h.264 video youtube 2009-09-01T11:56:39-05:00 45213 rentzsch Stuart A. Malone http://rentzsch.lighthouseapp.com/projects/24342/tickets/276 0 Just fresh-installed from 1.5fc2 in case I was running some weird half-between dev version and trashed my com.github.rentzsch.clicktoflash.plist prefs file, and still can't repro this. Perhaps was fixed between 1.5b5 and 1.5fc2? <div><p>Just fresh-installed from 1.5fc2 in case I was running some weird half-between dev version and trashed my com.github.rentzsch.clicktoflash.plist prefs file, and still can't repro this. Perhaps was fixed between 1.5b5 and 1.5fc2?</p></div> true 2009-09-01T12:01:09-05:00 68102 --- {} 276 video-element-always-set-to-autoplay-even-when-youtube-isnt 0 24342 cantreproduce 1.5fc2 autoplay h.264 video youtube 2009-09-01T12:01:13-05:00 45213 rentzsch Stuart A. Malone http://rentzsch.lighthouseapp.com/projects/24342/tickets/276 0 Ah, I'm dense. I needed to enable the "Load H.264 videos from YouTube" option. Reproduced. <div><p>Ah, I'm dense. I needed to enable the "Load H.264 videos from YouTube" option. Reproduced.</p></div> false 2009-09-01T12:02:56-05:00 68102 --- :state: cantreproduce 276 video-element-always-set-to-autoplay-even-when-youtube-isnt 0 24342 reproduced 1.5fc2 autoplay h.264 video youtube 2009-09-01T12:02:59-05:00 45213 rentzsch Stuart A. Malone http://rentzsch.lighthouseapp.com/projects/24342/tickets/276 0 Duplicate filed as 275 <div><p>Duplicate filed as 275</p></div> false 2009-09-04T01:18:26-05:00 68102 --- {} 276 video-element-always-set-to-autoplay-even-when-youtube-isnt 0 24342 reproduced 1.5fc2 autoplay h.264 video youtube 2009-09-04T01:18:26-05:00 45213 rentzsch Stuart A. Malone http://rentzsch.lighthouseapp.com/projects/24342/tickets/276 0 This started with my upgrade to Snow Leopard. <div><p>This started with my upgrade to Snow Leopard.</p></div> false 2009-09-05T10:00:51-05:00 68102 --- {} 276 video-element-always-set-to-autoplay-even-when-youtube-isnt 0 24342 reproduced 1.5fc2 autoplay h.264 video youtube 2009-09-05T10:00:55-05:00 68830 Rick Roberts Stuart A. Malone http://rentzsch.lighthouseapp.com/projects/24342/tickets/276 0 Note: Until this is fixed, the simple work-around is to disable the "Load H.264 videos from YouTube" option. <div><p>Note: Until this is fixed, the simple work-around is to disable the "Load H.264 videos from YouTube" option.</p></div> false 2009-09-05T13:37:12-05:00 68102 --- {} 276 video-element-always-set-to-autoplay-even-when-youtube-isnt 0 24342 reproduced 1.5fc2 autoplay h.264 video youtube 2009-09-05T13:37:13-05:00 45213 rentzsch Stuart A. Malone http://rentzsch.lighthouseapp.com/projects/24342/tickets/276 0 If you're into hacking some source code you can easily disable the autoplay by commenting out line 1343 in Plugin.m. This is off course a quick and dirty solution, but nonetheless a solution. <div><p>If you're into hacking some source code you can easily disable the autoplay by commenting out line 1343 in Plugin.m. This is off course a quick and dirty solution, but nonetheless a solution.</p></div> false 2009-09-05T13:48:12-05:00 68102 --- {} 276 video-element-always-set-to-autoplay-even-when-youtube-isnt 0 24342 reproduced 1.5fc2 autoplay h.264 video youtube 2009-09-05T13:48:16-05:00 68828 fppzdd Stuart A. Malone http://rentzsch.lighthouseapp.com/projects/24342/tickets/276 0 This might be a solution to the problem. It checks if the autoplay option is set for an embedded video, if it is it will autoplay and if we are on youtubes mainsite the videos autoplay, just as vanilla youtube would do. I really knwo how to present the changes I made to the source, but here comes the output of `git diff`: http://pastebin.com/f2c5a672d <div><p>This might be a solution to the problem.<br> It checks if the autoplay option is set for an embedded video, if it is it will autoplay and if we are on youtubes mainsite the videos autoplay, just as vanilla youtube would do.<br> I really knwo how to present the changes I made to the source, but here comes the output of <code>git diff</code>:<br> <a href= "http://pastebin.com/f2c5a672d">http://pastebin.com/f2c5a672d</a></p></div> false 2009-09-05T15:46:24-05:00 68102 --- {} 276 video-element-always-set-to-autoplay-even-when-youtube-isnt 0 24342 reproduced 1.5fc2 autoplay h.264 video youtube 2009-09-05T15:46:26-05:00 68828 fppzdd Stuart A. Malone http://rentzsch.lighthouseapp.com/projects/24342/tickets/276 0 Love to get this fixed :] <div><p>Love to get this fixed :]</p></div> false 2009-09-13T21:11:12-05:00 68102 --- {} 276 video-element-always-set-to-autoplay-even-when-youtube-isnt 0 24342 reproduced 1.5fc2 autoplay h.264 video youtube 2009-09-13T21:11:17-05:00 69572 wasabe34 Stuart A. Malone http://rentzsch.lighthouseapp.com/projects/24342/tickets/276 0 Love to get this fixed :] <div><p>Love to get this fixed :]</p></div> false 2009-09-13T21:11:12-05:00 68102 --- {} 276 video-element-always-set-to-autoplay-even-when-youtube-isnt 0 24342 reproduced 1.5fc2 autoplay h.264 video youtube 2009-09-13T21:11:17-05:00 69572 wasabe34 Stuart A. Malone http://rentzsch.lighthouseapp.com/projects/24342/tickets/276 0 srry, double post...dunno how to delete <div><p>srry, double post...dunno how to delete</p></div> false 2009-09-13T21:13:18-05:00 68102 --- {} 276 video-element-always-set-to-autoplay-even-when-youtube-isnt 0 24342 reproduced 1.5fc2 autoplay h.264 video youtube 2009-09-13T21:13:23-05:00 69572 wasabe34 Stuart A. Malone http://rentzsch.lighthouseapp.com/projects/24342/tickets/276 0 Under SL 10.6.1, Safari 4.0.3 and CtF 1.5.2 I can reproduce this behaviour and it is driving me nuts. "Until this is fixed, the simple work-around is to disable the "Load H.264 videos from YouTube" option." So true. <div><p>Under SL 10.6.1, Safari 4.0.3 and CtF 1.5.2 I can reproduce this behaviour and it is driving me nuts.</p> <p>"Until this is fixed, the simple work-around is to disable the "Load H.264 videos from YouTube" option."</p> <p>So true.</p></div> false 2009-09-15T02:33:30-05:00 68102 --- {} 276 video-element-always-set-to-autoplay-even-when-youtube-isnt 0 24342 reproduced 1.5fc2 autoplay h.264 video youtube 2009-09-15T02:33:32-05:00 45443 angelday Stuart A. Malone http://rentzsch.lighthouseapp.com/projects/24342/tickets/276 0 angelday: the reproduction is easy -- it's correcting it that's harder. I'd dig in myself, but I'm swamped. So until I get a pull request fixing the bug or I get a breather in a few weeks, the work-around is all we have. <div><p>angelday: the reproduction is easy -- it's correcting it that's harder. I'd dig in myself, but I'm swamped. So until I get a pull request fixing the bug or I get a breather in a few weeks, the work-around is all we have.</p></div> false 2009-09-15T14:02:54-05:00 68102 --- {} 276 video-element-always-set-to-autoplay-even-when-youtube-isnt 0 24342 reproduced 1.5fc2 autoplay h.264 video youtube 2009-09-15T14:02:55-05:00 45213 rentzsch Stuart A. Malone http://rentzsch.lighthouseapp.com/projects/24342/tickets/276 0 please try 1.5.3b2, which should fix this: <http://cloud.github.com/downloads/rentzsch/clicktoflash/ClickToFlash-1.5.3b2.zip> it incorporates fppzdd's patch: <http://github.com/rentzsch/clicktoflash/commit/fad0a55b1fa86829bc96eb7f3a49d081a00edba8> <div><p>please try 1.5.3b2, which should fix this: <a href= "http://cloud.github.com/downloads/rentzsch/clicktoflash/ClickToFlash-1.5.3b2.zip"> http://cloud.github.com/downloads/rentzsch/clicktoflash/ClickToFlash-1.5.3b2.zip</a></p> <p>it incorporates fppzdd's patch: <a href= "http://github.com/rentzsch/clicktoflash/commit/fad0a55b1fa86829bc96eb7f3a49d081a00edba8"> http://github.com/rentzsch/clicktoflash/commit/fad0a55b1fa86829bc96eb7f3a49d081a00edba8</a></p></div> true 2009-09-15T15:21:04-05:00 68102 --- :state: reproduced 276 video-element-always-set-to-autoplay-even-when-youtube-isnt 0 24342 fixcommitted 1.5fc2 autoplay h.264 video youtube 2009-09-15T15:21:11-05:00 45213 rentzsch Stuart A. Malone http://rentzsch.lighthouseapp.com/projects/24342/tickets/276 0 Latest beta seems to have fixed this. rentzsch, on the side line: no offense, you have done more to this project than anyone could wish for. <div><p>Latest beta seems to have fixed this.</p> <p>rentzsch, on the side line: no offense, you have done more to this project than anyone could wish for.</p></div> true 2009-09-16T02:58:25-05:00 68102 --- {} 276 video-element-always-set-to-autoplay-even-when-youtube-isnt 0 24342 fixcommitted 1.5fc2 autoplay h.264 video youtube 2009-09-16T02:58:30-05:00 45443 angelday Stuart A. Malone http://rentzsch.lighthouseapp.com/projects/24342/tickets/276 0 fix released in 1.5.3 <div><p>fix released in 1.5.3</p></div> true 2009-10-03T23:54:14-05:00 68102 --- :state: fixcommitted 276 video-element-always-set-to-autoplay-even-when-youtube-isnt 0 24342 fixreleased 1.5fc2 autoplay h.264 video youtube 2009-10-03T23:54:20-05:00 45213 rentzsch Stuart A. Malone http://rentzsch.lighthouseapp.com/projects/24342/tickets/276